Which olive oils pass the extra virgin lab tests?

Our pick is California Olive Ranch 100% California, 2 L, $54.99 ($27.50 a liter). It has no failed test in 14 years, and Consumer Reports named it in 2024. Price checked Nov 19, 2026.*1, 8

Check price on Amazon

Most results below are old, and each one carries its year and tester. The record, brand by brand

By Fine Print Nutrition editors · Published · 149 test results read · How we check

Our pick

California Olive Ranch 100% California extra virgin olive oil, 2 L bag-in-box

California Olive Ranch 100% California Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 2 L bag-in-box

What the public tests found, newest first

2024Consumer Reports Named the 100% California Medium oil as standing out for flavor and value; scores are for members*8
2015National Consumers League Passed: classified extra virgin*7
2011UC Davis, bottles bought in 2010 Passed: 0 of 18 failed both taste panels*4
2010UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010 Passed: both samples extra virgin*3
2023, 2026ConsumerLab three California Olive Ranch products tested each time; results not public*10, 11
Harvest yearOn the box’s QR code*2
Price$54.99 for 2 L*1

Check price on Amazon

Price checked Nov 19, 2026.

How we pick. Four checks, then price.

  1. The listing is plain extra virgin, not a blend.
  2. The brand passed every independent test we found that names it.
  3. The brand passed a test in the last 3 years, or the bottle prints a 2024/25 harvest.
  4. Amazon sells it today, in 3 liters or less.

The lowest price per liter wins. Only 1 of the 6 clean brands sold on Amazon has a test from the last 3 years: this one.*1, 2

The record, brand by brand

31 brands from 149 test results. Each row shows the newest test; the download has every one. A result from 2010 to 2012 says what the testers found in the bottles they bought then, not what is on the shelf today.*3, 4, 6

The record, brand by brand
BrandNewest testResult
California Olive Ranch
Check price on Amazon $27.50 a liter
2024, Consumer Reports*8 (4 tests)Passed every named test
Aldi2024, Consumer Reports*8Named a standout
Monini2021, Il Salvagente, Italy*9Passed
Trader Joe's2015, National Consumers League*7 (2 tests)Passed every named test
Corto2012, UC Davis, food service oils*5 (2 tests)Passed every named test
De Cecco2012, UC Davis, food service oils*5Passed
Kirkland Signature2012, Consumer Reports*6 (2 tests)Passed every named test
McEvoy Ranch2012, Consumer Reports*6 (2 tests)Passed every named test
O Olive Oil2012, UC Davis, food service oils*5Passed
Supremo Italiano2012, UC Davis, food service oils*5Passed
Cobram Estate
Check price on Amazon $21.31 a liter
2011, UC Davis, bottles bought in 2010*4Passed
Lucero2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010*3Passed
Bertolli2021, Il Salvagente, Italy*9 (4 tests)Passed some, failed some
Colavita2015, National Consumers League*7 (3 tests)Passed some, failed some
Lucini2015, National Consumers League*7 (2 tests)Passed some, failed some
365 (Whole Foods)2012, Consumer Reports*6 (2 tests)Passed some, failed some
Botticelli2012, Consumer Reports*6Failed
Capatriti2012, Consumer Reports*6Failed
Crisco2012, Consumer Reports*6Failed
Filippo Berio2012, Consumer Reports*6 (3 tests)Failed every named test
Goya2012, Consumer Reports*6Failed
Mazola2012, Consumer Reports*6 (2 tests)Failed every named test
Pompeian2011, UC Davis, bottles bought in 2010*4 (2 tests)Failed every named test
Star2011, UC Davis, bottles bought in 2010*4 (2 tests)Failed every named test
Bariani2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010*31 of the samples failed
Carapelli2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010*3All 3 samples failed
Great Value (Walmart)2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010*31 of the samples failed
Mezzetta2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010*3All 3 samples failed
Newman's Own Organics2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010*32 of the samples failed
Rachael Ray2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010*32 of the samples failed
Safeway Select2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010*32 of the samples failed

Prices are Amazon’s on Nov 19, 2026. Also in the 2023 or 2026 ConsumerLab test sets, results not public: Bertolli, California Olive Ranch, Carapelli, Colavita, Goya, Kirkland Signature, Lucini, Trader Joe's.*1, 10, 11

Download all 149 test results (CSV)

The biggest test: bottles bought in 2010, UC Davis report of 2011

UC Davis bought oils from three leading California supermarket chains in fall 2010. Of 90 samples from the five top imported brands, 66 failed both extra virgin taste panels. California Olive Ranch and Cobram Estate had none that failed.*4

Pompeian17 of 18Filippo Berio15 of 18Bertolli13 of 18Star11 of 18Colavita10 of 18Lucini2 of 18California Olive Ranch0 of 18Cobram Estate0 of 8

Samples that failed both taste panels, from bottles bought in 2010 (UC Davis report of April 2011). Black bars are brands with failures.*4

Brands change between tests. Colavita failed the bottles bought in 2010, then passed a National Consumers League test in 2015. Lucini had 2 of 18 samples fail, then passed in 2015.*4, 7

How to read the results

Extra virgin must pass chemistry tests and a taste panel. Most failures here were taste.*4, 13

How to read the results
Word in the tableWhat the tester didExample
PassedThe oil was graded extra virgin, or classified extra virgin.National Consumers League, 2015
FailedAt least one sample was graded below extra virgin, or tasted stale or barnyard-like.Consumer Reports, 2012
Named a standoutPraise for flavor and value. No pass mark and no score is public.Consumer Reports, 2024

The 2010 tests bought two or three samples per brand. The 2011 tests bought 8 to 18, so “none of 18” says more than “all 3”. The 2012 rows are oils bought through food service distributors, which may not match a store-shelf bottle.*3–5

Are Costco, Trader Joe’s and Walmart olive oils real extra virgin?

In the public tests we could read, Kirkland Signature (Costco) and Trader Joe’s oils passed, and one of three Walmart Great Value samples did not. The newest of these results is from 2015.*3, 6, 7

Are Costco, Trader Joe’s and Walmart olive oils real extra virgin?
Store brandWhat the tests found
Kirkland Signature (Costco)2012, Consumer Reports: the Select Toscano met the extra virgin criteria and was a Best Buy.*6
2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010: all 3 samples of Kirkland Organic were extra virgin.*3
Trader Joe’s2015, National Consumers League: two Trader Joe’s oils were classified extra virgin.*7
2012, Consumer Reports: California Estate rated Excellent and a Best Buy.*6
Great Value (Walmart)2010, UC Davis, bottles bought in March 2010: 2 of 3 samples were extra virgin and 1 was graded only virgin.*3

Newer tests that name products but not which failed

These tests list the oils they tested, or name no brands, and keep the results for members. They change no brand’s record above.

Newer tests that name products but not which failed
YearWho testedWhat they found
2015National Consumers League11 oils bought in Washington, D.C. stores; 5 were extra virgin. The 6 that failed were not named.*7
2023ConsumerLab13 oils, 9 graded not extra virgin by an expert taster. In the set: California Olive Ranch (3 products), Carapelli, Colavita, Goya, Gundry MD, Kirkland Signature, Life Extension, Lucini, Spectrum, Terra Delyssa and Trader Joe's. Which oils failed is for members only.*10
2024North American Olive Oil Association study (industry-funded)8 of 158 extra virgin samples (5%) failed more than one chemistry test. Brands are not named.*12
2026ConsumerLab11 oils, 3 failed the taste panel although all passed the chemistry tests. In the set: Atlas, Bertolli, Bragg, California Olive Ranch (3 products), Graza (2 products), Kirkland Signature (2 products) and Terra Delyssa. Which oils failed is for members only.*11

Read retests with care. The 2024 study says its samples sat 4.3 months on average before the last test. A failure does not prove the oil failed on the day it was bought.*12

Questions people ask

Do the store brands from Costco, Trader Joe’s and Walmart pass?

In the public tests we read, Kirkland Signature and Trader Joe’s passed between 2010 and 2015. One of three Walmart Great Value samples was graded only virgin in 2010.*3, 6, 7

Did Bertolli and Filippo Berio fail the extra virgin tests?

In the 2011 UC Davis report, 13 of 18 Bertolli samples failed both taste panels, from bottles bought in 2010. So did 15 of 18 Filippo Berio samples. Consumer Reports rated both stale in 2012.*4, 6

Has a court ruled that a brand is not extra virgin?

Not in the cases we read. A Bertolli class action settled for $7 million in 2018 with no ruling on the oil.*14–16

Does a pass in an old test mean the oil is good today?

No. A test describes the bottles bought that year. Oil ages on the shelf, and makers change suppliers, so look for a harvest year on the bottle you buy.*4

Review log

  • : Published

Notes and sources

  1. Amazon US product data for olive oil, 8 searches, Nov 19, 2026: titles, brands and prices for 178 listings. Prices were refreshed on the build day.
  2. Amazon listing photos and text, labels read by eye on Nov 19, 2026. Back labels are small in Amazon photos, so a detail counts only when it is visible on the label or in the listing.
  3. UC Davis Olive Center, retail olive oil study, report July 2010 (bottles bought the week of March 3, 2010; Australian Oils Research Laboratory) A slide copy of the report. 19 brands.
  4. UC Davis Olive Center, report on imported extra virgin olive oil sold in California, April 2011 (bottles bought Sep to Oct 2010) Two stores of three leading supermarkets in each of three regions. The methods table is the source for the test limits.
  5. UC Davis Olive Center, report on olive oil sold to restaurants and food service, September 2012. Oils bought through food service distributors, not from store shelves.
  6. Consumer Reports, olive oil press release, July 2012 (September 2012 issue) 138 bottles from 23 makers.
  7. National Consumers League, olive oil test, released May 19, 2015 (bottles bought Jan 2015; lab: Australian Oils Research Laboratory) The six failing brands were not named.
  8. Consumer Reports olive oil taste test, Feb 2024, as reported by Click On Detroit. A local TV report. Consumer Reports shows the full ratings to members only.
  9. Il Salvagente (Italy), olive oil test, reported Apr 30, 2021, panel of the Agenzia delle Dogane laboratory in Rome. Italian shelf oils.
  10. ConsumerLab, olive oil testing news release, Apr 10, 2023. The release does not name the nine.
  11. ConsumerLab, extra virgin olive oil review news release, Sep 30, 2026. The free text does not name the three.
  12. North American Olive Oil Association, 2024 olive oil testing study (industry-funded; Yale researcher Tassos Kyriakides), 216 retail samples bought Sep to Dec 2024 (158 extra virgin labeled samples had chemistry tests) Brands are not named.
  13. USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, "Olive Oil and Olive-Pomace Oil Grades and Standards". The voluntary U.S. grade for extra virgin.
  14. Olive Oil Times, "Filippo Berio and Bertolli class action". Koller v. Deoleo.
  15. Olive Oil Times, on the Fahey v. Deoleo dismissal, 2018. Dismissed in full.
  16. Olive Oil Times, Filippo Berio payout, 50 cents a bottle. Kumar v. Salov. The final approval was not verified.