What is the cheapest olive oil with a recent extra virgin test pass?
Our pick is California Olive Ranch, six 1-liter bottles: $24.67 a liter ($148.00 in all). Consumer Reports named the brand’s Medium oil as a standout in 2024.*1, 8
Our pick

California Olive Ranch Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 6 x 1,000 mL (6 L)
What the record shows
How we pick. Four checks.
- The listing is plain extra virgin olive oil, sold on Amazon in any size.
- Its brand has no failed or mixed public test record.
- It has a passing test from 2023 or later, or a 2024/25 harvest with a printed method or lab certificate.
- Of those, ours has the lowest price per liter.
Six levels of proof, cheapest first
The cheapest bottle for each kind of proof, with its size. Prices are Amazon’s on Nov 19, 2026.*1
| Level | Proof | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Cheapest, with an old test passSupremo Italiano Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 3 L tin, 3 L | 2012, UC Davis, food service oils: passed all 3 taste panels.*5 | $12.63 a liter $37.88 for 3 L |
| Old test pass and a sealCobram Estate Classic California Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 750 mL | 2011, UC Davis, bottles bought in 2010: none of 8 samples failed.*4 On the California Olive Oil Council’s 2025 list.*10 | $21.31 a liter $15.98 for 750 mL |
| A current sealLa Tourangelle Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 500 mL | On the North American Olive Oil Association’s seal list. Each product is certified one by one.*9 | $23.98 a liter $11.99 for 500 mL |
![]() Our pick: a test pass in the last 3 yearsCalifornia Olive Ranch 100% California Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 6 x 1,000 mL (6 L) | 2024, Consumer Reports named the 100% California Medium oil as standing out; size not stated.*8 Earlier passes in 2015, 2011, 2010.*3, 4, 7 | $24.67 a liter $148.00 for 6 x 1,000 mL (6 L) Check price on Amazon |
![]() A 2024/25 harvest and a printed methodP.J. Kabos Family Reserve Medium Greek Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 3 x 500 mL (1.5 L) | Harvest 2025/26. The maker reports 400+ mg/kg of polyphenols by a lab method called HPLC.*2 | $32.12 a liter $48.18 for 3 x 500 mL (1.5 L) Check price on Amazon |
![]() A named-lab certificate and a 2024/25 harvestWellEatable High +1,200 mg/kg Organic Olive Oil, 500 mL | Harvest 2025/26. Certificate from the World Olive Center for Health: 1,382 mg/kg of polyphenols.*2 | $81.14 a liter $40.57 for 500 mL Check price on Amazon |
Cheaper bottles with no recent proof
Failed or mixed public tests (26): Pompeian (12), Bertolli (3), 365 by Whole Foods Market (5), Colavita (5), Carapelli. See the record.*2
No test, seal or recent harvest found (27): Amazon Fresh or Grocery (7), Terra Creta (3), Baja Precious, Sulu Organics, Montinaro, Graza, Mythology, Atlas (2), Lyrakis Family, Iliada (3), Minerva, Pantaleo, Mina, Mr. Papou's, Bragg, Partanna.*2
Only an old test or a seal, no recent harvest (6): Supremo Italiano, De Cecco (3), Cobram Estate, La Tourangelle.*2
Kirkland Signature and Trader Joe’s
| Store brand | Public tests |
|---|---|
| Kirkland Signature | Passed in 2012 (Consumer Reports) and in 2010 (UC Davis, bottles bought in 2010).*3, 6 |
| Trader Joe’s | Passed in 2015 (National Consumers League) and in 2012 (Consumer Reports).*6, 7 |
Both are sold in their own stores, not on Amazon.
The best extra virgin olive oil. Which olive oils pass the lab tests. Olive oils with lab-reported polyphenols. Which organic olive oils are really organic.
Questions people ask
What is the cheapest olive oil with a recent test pass?
It is California Olive Ranch’s 100% California oil in the six-bottle pack, from the Consumer Reports 2024 result. The cheapest bottle with an old test pass is Supremo Italiano, a 3 L tin, from a 2012 test.*5, 8
Does a higher price mean an oil passes?
Often, but price is not proof. 19 of the 33 bottles above $50 a liter have no public test or seal at all. Check the proof, then the price.*1, 2
Are Kirkland and Trader Joe’s olive oils on Amazon?
No. Both are sold in their own stores. Their public tests are in the table above.*3, 6, 7
How old can a test be?
The older the test, the less it says. Oil ages, and brands change suppliers. A harvest year on the bottle and a recent test say more than a pass from 2012.*13
Review log
- : Published
Notes and sources
- We read 144 extra virgin listings with a price on Amazon on Nov 19, 2026. Price per liter is the Amazon price divided by the liters in the listing, counting multi-packs. The sizes in the ladder run from 500 mL to 6 L.*1, 2
- A brand with a failed or mixed public record never counts. The record is on the lab-tested page. The 2012 test behind the lowest-price row covered food service oils.
- The picture at the top is AI-made and shows no real product.
- We’d change our pick when a cheaper bottle gets a recent public pass. Next check: January 2027. More: all olive oil pages and how we check.
- Amazon US product data for olive oil, 8 searches, Nov 19, 2026: titles, brands, prices and image links for 178 listings. Prices were refreshed on the build day.
- Amazon listing photos and text, labels read by eye on Nov 19, 2026. A detail counts only when it is visible on the label or in the listing.
- UC Davis Olive Center, retail olive oil study, report July 2010 (bottles bought the week of March 3, 2010; Australian Oils Research Laboratory) A slide copy of the report.
- UC Davis Olive Center, report on imported extra virgin olive oil sold in California, April 2011 (bottles bought Sep to Oct 2010) Two stores of three leading supermarkets in each of three regions.
- UC Davis Olive Center, report on olive oil sold to restaurants and food service, September 2012. Oils bought through food service distributors, not from store shelves.
- Consumer Reports, olive oil press release, July 2012 (September 2012 issue) 138 bottles from 23 makers.
- National Consumers League, olive oil test, released May 19, 2015 (bottles bought Jan 2015; lab: Australian Oils Research Laboratory) The six failing brands were not named.
- Consumer Reports olive oil taste test, Feb 2024, as reported by Click On Detroit. A local TV report. Consumer Reports shows the full ratings to members only.
- North American Olive Oil Association seal member list, read Nov 19, 2026. Members join the program; each product is certified one by one.
- California Olive Oil Council, certified oils for the 2025 harvest, read Nov 19, 2026. 49 producers are listed.
- ConsumerLab, olive oil testing news release, Apr 10, 2023. The release does not name the nine.
- ConsumerLab, extra virgin olive oil review news release, Sep 30, 2026. The free text does not name the three.
- UC Davis, "How to choose the best olive oil". Harvest date, how long oil keeps, light and heat.

