Olive oil: what the labels and tests show
Of 165 extra virgin olive oils on Amazon, only 25 print the year they were harvested, and the public test results are years old. Each page answers one buying question. We show the source for every number.
- What is the best extra virgin olive oil?
Our pick: PJ Kabos Family Reserve Medium, $32.12 a liter. Only 25 of 165 extra virgin oils on Amazon print a harvest year. Published . - Which olive oils pass the extra virgin lab tests?
Our pick: California Olive Ranch, $27.50 a liter. Every public extra virgin test we could open, by brand, with its year and lab. Published . - Which extra virgin olive oils have lab-reported polyphenols?
Our pick: WellEatable High +1,200, $81.14 a liter, with a lab certificate. All 39 olive oils that print a polyphenol number. Published . - Which organic extra virgin olive oils are really USDA Organic certified?
Our pick: OLIVEA Organic Greek, $39.98 a liter. We checked 71 organic claims against the USDA database; 30 are confirmed. Published . - What is the cheapest olive oil with a recent extra virgin test pass?
Our pick: California Olive Ranch, six 1-liter bottles, with a 2024 Consumer Reports result. Six levels of proof, cheapest first. Published .
How we work
How we check explains how we find tests, rate them and pick products. How we make money: we earn a commission when you buy through our Amazon links, and brands can’t pay to be included. Mistakes are fixed and logged on our corrections page.
Last updated .