Which protein powders are actually third-party tested?

Most “third-party tested” protein powders aren’t checked for what you care about. Of 74 on Amazon, 28 have proof someone checked the protein on the label. Only 7 of those 28 have a published lead result.*1, 4, 17

Our pick is Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey, Double Rich Chocolate. Consumer Reports found its protein matched the label and its lead at 56% of its limit. It costs $1.49 per 25 g of protein in the 5 lb tub.*17, 20

Check price on Amazon

About the same price: Body Fortress Whey, Vanilla, $1.56 per 25 g. Want an isolate: Dymatize ISO100, $2.12. Why these

By Fine Print Nutrition editors · Published · 74 listings matched to 7 registries, Consumer Reports and Clean Label Project on Nov 5, 2026 · How we check

74 protein powders on Amazon: who checked the protein, and who tested for lead
28 protein checkedby NSF or a lab46 not checkedbanned drugs or nothing

* Each dot is one Amazon listing. Filled: passed a lead test. Red: over Consumer Reports’ lead limit. Open: no published lead result.*4, 17, 19 Find your brand

Our pick

Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Double Rich Chocolate, 5 lb tub, 74 servings

Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Double Rich Chocolate, 5 lb

What the records show

Protein on the labelMatched Consumer Reports, 2025, chocolate*17
Lead56% of Consumer Reports’ limit 0.27 micrograms a serving*17
Banned sports drugsTested Informed Choice, Double Rich Chocolate batch, June 2026*12
Cost per 25 g of protein$1.49 $105.99; 74 servings of 24 g*1, 20

The lowest cost of the protein powders with both a label check and a published lead number.

Check price on Amazon

Price checked Nov 20, 2026. Whey isolate and concentrate, artificially flavored. Skip it if you want an unflavored or plant powder.*20

How we pick. First, a record must check the protein on the label for the exact flavor and size sold. Second, a lab must find lead under Consumer Reports’ limit in that flavor. 5 powders pass both. A published lead number beats a “not detected” with no number, and then the lowest cost wins.*4, 6, 17, 19

Compare our pick with the similarly priced and isolate options

Compare our pick with the similarly priced and isolate options
Amazon listingLeadProtein checkedPer 25 g of protein
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Double Rich Chocolate, 5 lb56% of Consumer Reports’ limit*17Consumer Reports test*17$1.49 Check price
Body Fortress Super Advanced Whey Protein, Vanilla, 3.9 lbNot detected Clean Label Project, no number*19NSF Contents Certified*7$1.56 Check price
Dymatize ISO100 Whey Isolate, Gourmet Vanilla, 20 servingsNot detected Clean Label Project, no number*19None found; Informed Choice tests banned drugs*13$2.12 Check price

Why not the Body Fortress that costs about the same? Its lead result is a Clean Label Project “not detected,” with no number and no detection limit, and Clean Label Project also sells certification to brands. Our pick has a measured number. Dymatize ISO100 is the pick if you want an isolate; Informed Choice tested a vanilla batch in June 2026, but for banned drugs, not protein.*1, 13, 17, 19

Why not Momentous or BPN? Both are NSF Certified for Sport for the tubs sold here. Neither has a published lead result for those tubs. Consumer Reports tested a Momentous isolate in 2025, but Momentous said that product was discontinued.*4, 16, 17

Why can an NSF-certified powder be over the lead limit?

Because NSF’s limit is 20 times looser. NSF allows up to 10 micrograms of lead a day, Consumer Reports says. Consumer Reports uses 0.5. Garden of Life Sport plant protein is NSF Certified for Sport. It had 2.76 micrograms a serving: under NSF’s limit, and 5.6 times Consumer Reports’.*4, 16, 17

NSF’s limit is also higher than the FDA’s. The FDA’s interim reference level for lead from food is 8.8 micrograms a day for women who could become pregnant and 2.2 for children, and it says no safe level of lead has been found. One scoop of the Garden of Life powder is 31% of that adult level. One scoop of our pick is 3%.*17, 22

NSF limit: 10FDA, women: 8.8Consumer Reports' limit: 0.5Dymatize Super Mass Gainer0.12Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard0.27Premier Protein 100% Whey0.38Orgain Organic Protein0.7Garden of Life Sport, plant2.76

Lead in one serving, in micrograms, for every powder here with a published number. Red: over Consumer Reports’ limit. Dashed lines: Consumer Reports’ limit, the FDA’s daily level for women who could become pregnant, and NSF’s limit.*16–18, 22

Certification doesn’t publish lead numbers. Of the 74 listings, 7 have a published lead number for the flavor sold, and 6 more have only Clean Label Project’s “not detected.”*17–19

Why can an NSF-certified powder be over the lead limit?
Amazon listing and its recordLead per serving
Body Fortress Super Advanced Whey Protein, Vanilla, 3.9 lbProtein on the label checkedNot detected Clean Label Project, vanilla*19
Dymatize Super Mass Gainer, Gourmet Vanilla, 6 lbProtein on the label checked25% of Consumer Reports’ limit 0.12 micrograms*17
Garden of Life Sport Organic Plant-Based Protein, Vanilla, 19 servingsProtein on the label checked564% of Consumer Reports’ limit 2.76 micrograms*17
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Double Rich Chocolate, 2 lbProtein on the label checked56% of Consumer Reports’ limit 0.27 micrograms*17
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Double Rich Chocolate, 5 lbProtein on the label checked56% of Consumer Reports’ limit 0.27 micrograms*17
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Double Rich Chocolate, 1 lbProtein on the label checked56% of Consumer Reports’ limit 0.27 micrograms*17
Orgain Organic Protein, Vanilla Bean, 2.03 lbProtein on the label checked143% of Consumer Reports’ limit 0.7 micrograms*17
Dymatize ISO100 Whey Isolate, Gourmet Vanilla, 20 servingsChecked for banned sports drugs onlyNot detected Clean Label Project, gourmet vanilla*19
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Vanilla Ice Cream, 2 lbBrand certified, not this flavor or sizeNot detected Clean Label Project, vanilla ice cream*19
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Vanilla Ice Cream, 5 lbBrand certified, not this flavor or sizeNot detected Clean Label Project, vanilla ice cream*19
Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Vanilla Ice Cream, 0.68 lbBrand certified, not this flavor or sizeNot detected Clean Label Project, vanilla ice cream*19
Isopure Zero Carb Whey Isolate, Unflavored, 2.55 lbNo claim, no recordNot detected Clean Label Project, unflavored*19
Premier Protein 100% Whey, Chocolate, 17 servingsNo claim, no record77% of Consumer Reports’ limit 0.38 micrograms*18

For lead numbers on the 30 best sellers, see the best protein powder. For the shortest ingredient lists, see the cleanest protein powder. For bars, see the best protein bar by label.*23

Does “NSF Certified” on an Amazon listing mean it is?

Not always. 8 of the 9 Naked Nutrition listings here say “NSF Certified.” None is on either NSF list. 7 are on Informed Choice instead, which tests for banned drugs. In 2025, Naked told Consumer Reports it was “in the process of obtaining” NSF certification.*4, 6, 11, 16

Others don’t match either. Sports Research says “NSF” and is only on Informed Sport. Garden of Life Raw Organic says “NSF Contents Certified” and isn’t on that list. Nutricost says it’s made in an NSF-certified facility, which is a factory audit, not a test of the powder.*4, 6, 8, 9

Is your brand’s protein powder third-party tested?

12 of the 33 brands here have proof for at least one listing. Find yours below. Each row shows the best record we found for that brand’s listings.*4, 6, 9, 10

Protein checked28Banned drugs only12Not this flavor or size8Says tested, no record9No claim, no record17

All 74 listings, grouped by the best record we found for each one.

Is your brand’s protein powder third-party tested?
BrandBest record we foundProtein checked?
Animal2 listingsInformed Choice (no current batch of this flavor)Not for the ones sold here
Ascent1 listingInformed Sport (Chocolate batch, 2026)No, banned drugs only
Bare Performance Nutrition (BPN)1 listingNSF Certified for Sport
Informed Sport (Vanilla batch, 2025)
Yes
Body Fortress3 listingsNSF Contents CertifiedYes, all 3 listings
Core Med Science1 listingNSF Certified for Sport (Amazon names no flavor)Not for the ones sold here
Dymatize3 listingsInformed Choice (Gourmet Vanilla batch, 2026)
Consumer Reports protein test (met the label, 2025)
Yes, 1 of 3 listings
Garden of Life3 listingsNSF Certified for Sport
Informed Choice (no current batch of this flavor)
Consumer Reports protein test (met the label, 2025)
Yes, 2 of 3 listings
Just Ingredients1 listingNSF Certified for Sport (another size)Not for the ones sold here
Klean Athlete2 listingsNSF Certified for Sport (another size)
NSF Contents Certified
Yes, both listings
Momentous3 listingsNSF Certified for Sport
NSF Contents Certified
Yes, all 3 listings
Muscle Milk6 listingsNSF Certified for SportYes, all 6 listings
Naked Nutrition9 listingsInformed Choice (Unflavored batch, 2025)No, banned drugs only
Optimum Nutrition8 listingsNSF Certified for Sport (another size)
Informed Choice (Double Rich Chocolate batch, 2026)
Consumer Reports protein test (met the label, 2025)
Yes, 3 of 8 listings
Orgain4 listingsConsumer Reports protein test (met the label, 2025)Yes, 1 of 4 listings
Sports Research1 listingInformed Sport (Dutch Chocolate batch, 2026)No, banned drugs only
Thorne3 listingsNSF Certified for Sport
NSF Contents Certified
Yes, all 3 listings
Transparent Labs2 listingsNSF Certified for Sport
Informed Choice (French Vanilla batch, 2026)
Informed Protein
Yes, both listings
Vega1 listingNSF Certified for Sport (another size)
NSF Contents Certified
Yes

We found no record for these 15 brands: BSN, Clean Simple Eats, Earth Fed Muscle, FlavCity, Isopure, It's Just!, Jocko Fuel, Levels Nutrition, MuscleTech, NutraBio, Nutricost, Premier Protein, Purely Inspired, Raw Organic Whey, Six Star.*4, 6, 9, 10, 15

Source: Amazon US results for "third party tested protein powder" and "nsf certified protein powder," Nov 5, 2026, matched to 7 registries*1 · Download CSV · Free to reuse with credit to Fine Print Nutrition

A brand’s other flavors and sizes can have a different record. Every listing, with its claim and record, is in the CSV.

Our pick: Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard Whey, Double Rich Chocolate, 5 lb. Protein checked, lead at 56% of Consumer Reports’ limit, $1.49 per 25 g. Check price on Amazon*17, 20

What does each “tested” mark check on a protein powder?

Only the two NSF marks and Informed Protein check the protein amount. Informed Sport and Informed Choice check for banned sports drugs.

What does each “tested” mark check on a protein powder?
MarkWhat it says it checksProtein amountBanned drugsContaminants
NSF Certified for Sport“what is on the label matches what is in the product”*2YesYes (290)Yes; lead limit 10 micrograms a day per Consumer Reports
NSF Contents Certified“Label claim review to certify that what's on the label is in the bottle”*5YesNo (Sport is a separate add-on)Yes, "unacceptable levels of contaminants"
Informed Sport“every batch of a product has been tested for more than 285 substances prohibited in sport”*9Not statedYes (285+), every batchNot stated
Informed Choice“the product has been regularly tested for prohibited substances in certified dietary supplements”*10Not statedYes, "regularly tested"Not stated
Informed Protein“total protein (via the determination of total nitrogen), total carbon, free amino acids, and a range of nitrogen-rich adulterants”*14Yes, and checks for amino spikingNoBrand submits its own heavy-metal results
"Made in an NSF-certified facility"“your product is manufactured utilizing industry best practices”*8No (factory audit)NoNo

Quotes are from each program’s own pages, read Nov 5, 2026. “Not stated” means its pages didn’t say. BSCG and USP Verified list no powder in this set.*15

Does any mark check for amino spiking? Only Informed Protein. Amino spiking means adding cheap amino acids so a lab reads more protein than the powder has. Informed Protein tests for that and retests at least monthly. Of these 74, only Transparent Labs’ whey isolate carries it.*14

How to check a protein powder before you buy

Three checks take about five minutes.

  1. Search the registry, not the label. Type the brand into the search box at nsfsport.com, NSF’s supplement listings, or the Informed Choice site. A seal in an Amazon photo is not proof.*4, 6, 10
  2. Match the flavor and size. NSF lists Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard only in 10 lb tubs. Informed pages list each tested batch by flavor, and a flavor with no current batch isn’t covered today.*4, 12
  3. Look for a lead number separately. Certification doesn’t publish lead results. Consumer Reports and Clean Label Project do, for some powders.*17, 19

Questions people ask

Is Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard whey third-party tested?
Yes, in Double Rich Chocolate, our pick. Consumer Reports found its protein met the label and its lead at 56% of its limit. Informed Choice tested a batch in June 2026 for banned drugs. NSF Certified for Sport lists only the 10 lb tub.*4, 12, 17
Is Naked Whey NSF certified?
We found no NSF record for it. Naked Whey and Naked Pea are not on NSF Certified for Sport or NSF Contents Certified. They are on Informed Choice, which tests for banned substances. In 2025, Naked told Consumer Reports it was "in the process of obtaining" NSF certification.*4, 6, 11, 16
Is Transparent Labs protein third-party tested?
Yes. Its grass-fed whey isolate is on NSF Certified for Sport for the French Vanilla and Milk Chocolate tubs sold here, on Informed Choice, and on Informed Protein. We found no public lead test for it.*4, 10, 14
Is Garden of Life protein NSF certified and safe?
Its Sport plant protein is NSF Certified for Sport. Consumer Reports found 2.76 micrograms of lead per serving in the vanilla, 564% of its limit. That is under NSF's 10 microgram limit, which is 20 times higher.*4, 16, 17
Is Dymatize ISO100 third-party tested?
Yes, for banned substances. Informed Choice tested Gourmet Vanilla in June 2026 and Gourmet Chocolate in October 2025. No program we found checks its protein amount. Clean Label Project found no lead in the vanilla.*13, 19

Review log

  • Prices and stock checked on Amazon November 20, 2026.
  • : Published

Notes and sources

  • Fine Print Ledger: we searched Amazon US for “third party tested protein powder” and “nsf certified protein powder” through Amazon’s own search service on Nov 5, 2026 and kept the first 50 results of each. That gave 75 listings; we left out one creatine powder. A shopper may see a different order. Each listing’s claim is quoted from its title and bullet points.*1
  • One counting rule: each listing goes in one group by its strongest record for that exact product, flavor and size. Label checked = NSF Certified for Sport (size listed), NSF Contents Certified (NSF/ANSI 173), or Consumer Reports’ 2025 protein test of the same product and flavor. Banned-substance list only = a current Informed Sport or Informed Choice batch of that flavor. Brand listed, not this flavor or size = the product is on a registry, but not this flavor or size, or no current batch. Every registry match is by name; no registry shows a barcode.*4, 6, 9, 10
  • A record counts only for the same product and flavor. NSF Certified for Sport must also list the size sold. NSF Contents Certified covers every size of a listed flavor. Informed Sport and Choice count only when a batch of that flavor is on the product page today. NSF doesn’t say which lots of a Contents Certified product it tested.*3, 5, 10
  • Registries searched Nov 5, 2026: NSF Certified for Sport (by brand, 868 listings opened), NSF/ANSI 173 (1,258 products), Informed Sport and Informed Choice (by brand, with product pages), Informed Protein, BSCG (670 protein lots, none from these brands) and USP Verified (no protein powder). “None found” means we found nothing in those places. It doesn’t mean a claim is false.*4, 6, 9, 10, 14, 15
  • Lead: Consumer Reports tested 23 products in 2025 and 5 more in January 2026, at a lab it doesn’t name; its limit is 0.5 micrograms a day. Consumer Reports tested “Gold Standard 100% Whey, Chocolate,” which we match to Double Rich Chocolate, as our best protein powder page does. Clean Label Project tested in 2023–24 and published only the list of powders with no lead detected, with no numbers or detection limit. A result counts only for the flavor tested. Momentous told Consumer Reports its tested products were discontinued, so we don’t count those results.*16–19
  • Cost per 25 g of protein = price ÷ (servings × grams of protein per serving) × 25. Optimum Nutrition 5 lb: 74 servings of 24 g, and Body Fortress: 39 servings of 30 g, both read from the panels in their Amazon photos. Dymatize ISO100: 20 servings of 25 g, from its Amazon title.*1, 20, 21
  • We’d change our pick after a failed test, a lost listing, or a cheaper powder with a published lead number that passes both checks. Next check: February 2027. More: the best protein powder, all our protein pages and how we check.
  1. Amazon US search results for "third party tested protein powder" and "nsf certified protein powder" (Amazon Creators API, first 50 results each, Nov 5, 2026), with each listing's title and bullet points. 75 listings; one creatine powder left out. Prices change often.
  2. NSF Certified for Sport, "What our mark means," read Nov 5, 2026
  3. NSF Certified for Sport, "Get certified," read Nov 5, 2026
  4. NSF Certified for Sport listings, searched by brand name for every brand here and opened one by one (868 listings), Nov 5, 2026. Listing numbers for each product are in the CSV.
  5. NSF, "Supplement and vitamin certification" (NSF/ANSI 173, "Contents Certified"), read Nov 5, 2026
  6. NSF/ANSI 173 dietary supplement listings, searched by product and brand words (1,258 products), Nov 5, 2026
  7. NSF/ANSI 173 listing: Body Fortress Super Advanced Whey Protein, Vanilla (product ID "All"), Nov 5, 2026
  8. NSF, "GMP certification and registration," read Nov 5, 2026
  9. Informed Sport, "Certification process" and product pages with batch lists, read Nov 5, 2026
  10. Informed Choice, "Certification process" and product pages with batch lists, read Nov 5, 2026. A batch stays on a product page until it expires.
  11. Informed Choice: Naked Whey and Naked Pea product pages (batches by flavor), read Nov 5, 2026
  12. Informed Choice: ON Gold Standard 100% Whey product page (batches by flavor), read Nov 5, 2026
  13. Informed Choice: Dymatize ISO100 Hydrolyzed Protein Powder (USA) product page, read Nov 5, 2026
  14. Informed Protein (LGC), certification process and certified list, read Nov 5, 2026
  15. BSCG Certified Drug Free database, searched "protein" and "whey" (670 lots from 18 brands; none in this set), Nov 5, 2026
  16. Consumer Reports, "Protein Powders and Shakes Contain High Levels of Lead," Oct 14, 2025 (updated Jan 8, 2026) Also the source for NSF's 10 microgram lead limit and Naked Nutrition's statement.
  17. Consumer Reports, protein powders and shakes: methodology and test results (PDF), 2025. Micrograms per serving and the flavor tested.
  18. Consumer Reports, protein supplements test methodology and results (PDF), January 2026
  19. Clean Label Project, "Clean Sixteen" protein powders one-sheet (no lead, cadmium, mercury or arsenic detected) Study tested 2023 to 2024, published Jan 9, 2025. No numbers or detection limit published.
  20. Amazon listing for Optimum Nutrition Gold Standard 100% Whey, Double Rich Chocolate, 5 lb: tub and Nutrition Facts panel in the listing photos (74 servings of 24 g protein; "artificially flavored"), read Nov 5, 2026
  21. Amazon listing for Body Fortress Super Advanced Whey Protein, Vanilla, 3.9 lb: Supplement Facts panel in the listing photos, read Nov 5, 2026
  22. U.S. Food and Drug Administration, "Lead in Food and Foodwares" (interim reference levels: 2.2 micrograms a day for children, 8.8 for females of childbearing age), content current as of Jan 6, 2025
  23. Fine Print Nutrition, "What is the best protein powder to buy?" (the 30 best sellers and their lead results)