Are Fairlife protein shakes good?
Fairlife shakes are good protein, 26 to 42 g a bottle. But they cost more per gram than most shakes: a median $3.73 per 30 g, against $2.89 for all 156 we priced. 14 of the 19 labels list carrageenan, and 15 list artificial sweeteners.*1, 2
If you want Fairlife, buy Core Power Elite 42 g, Chocolate. It costs $2.32 per 30 g of protein, the lowest of the 9 listings we could fully read.*1, 2
Other options: Core Power 26 g, Vanilla for a smaller bottle with fewer calories ($2.68 a bottle), or Premier Protein 30 g, Chocolate Peanut Butter if you want it cheaper per gram. Why these
* Each dot is one Amazon listing with a label we could read. Red: carrageenan on the ingredient list. Open: label too small to read.*2 The rule
Which Fairlife shake should you buy?

Core Power Elite 42 g, Chocolate, 12 Bottles
What the Core Power Elite label shows
1234
- 142 g of protein in one 14 fl oz (414 mL) bottle, with 230 calories.*2
- 27 g of sugar, 0 g added. It is the natural sugar in the milk.*2
- 3Carrageenan is on the list, with cellulose gel and cellulose gum. The first ingredient is “Filtered Lowfat Grade A Milk,” and the label says “Contains: milk.”*2
- 4Four sweeteners: acesulfame potassium, monk fruit juice concentrate, stevia leaf extract and sucralose. Enlarged from the label photo on the Amazon listing.*2
How we pick. We kept Fairlife and Core Power shakes with a label we read with high confidence, one flavor, a usable price and a seller that is not a reseller. 9 listings pass. We ranked them by cost per 30 g of protein, and Elite Chocolate ranked first. The next table shows all 15 single-flavor listings with a readable label, resellers included.*1, 2
Two other options
Want a smaller, cheaper bottle? Core Power 26 g, Vanilla costs $2.68 a bottle in the 12-pack and has 170 calories instead of 230. It costs more per gram of protein than Elite.*1, 2
Want it cheaper? Premier Protein 30 g, Chocolate Peanut Butter costs less per gram of protein, and it is also made with milk. It also lists carrageenan and sucralose, and it has no lead test either.*1, 2
Want a shake with a lead test? The one shake Consumer Reports found under its lead limit is OWYN Pro Elite chocolate in the 330 ml carton. No Fairlife or Core Power shake has a lead test. See the full lead results.*5, 12
Fairlife Nutrition Plan is the Fairlife shake most people ask about. We found it only from a reseller, and its ingredient list is too small to read, so it isn’t our pick.*2
Which Fairlife and Core Power shakes are the best buy?
Core Power Elite 42 g costs the least per gram of the shakes we could fully read: $2.32 to $3.77 per 30 g of protein.*1, 2
| Amazon listing | Label and cost |
|---|---|
1. Core Power Elite 42 g, ChocolateAmazon · $38.99 for 12 | 42 g · 7 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $2.32 per 30 g |
2. Core Power 26 g, VanillaAmazon · $32.19 for 12 | 26 g · 5 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $3.10 per 30 g |
3. Core Power 26 g, Strawberry BananaAmazon · $34.84 for 12 | 26 g · 6 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $3.35 per 30 g |
4. Core Power Elite 42 g, VanillaAmazon · $56.52 for 12 | 42 g · 8 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $3.37 per 30 g |
5. Core Power Elite 42 g, StrawberryAmazon · $57.03 for 12 | 42 g · 7 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $3.39 per 30 g |
6. Core Power Elite 42 g, VanillaAmazon · $125.47 for 24 | 42 g · 8 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $3.73 per 30 g |
7. Core Power Elite 42 g, ChocolateAmazon · $5.28 for 1 | 42 g · 7 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $3.77 per 30 g |
8. Core Power 26 g, ChocolateAmazon · $41.88 for 12 | 26 g · 5 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $4.03 per 30 g |
9. Core Power 26 g, Strawberry BananaAmazon · $3.88 for 1 | 26 g · 6 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $4.48 per 30 g |
10. Core Power Elite 42 g, VanillaAmazon · $4.29 for 1 | 42 g · 8 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $3.06 per 30 g |
11. Fairlife Nutrition Plan 30 g, ChocolateAmazon · $37.31 for 12 · reseller | 30 g · 2 g sugar · carrageenan: label too small to read · $3.11 per 30 g |
12. Core Power Elite 42 g, ChocolateAmazon · $66.90 for 12 · reseller | 42 g · 7 g sugar · carrageenan: label too small to read · $3.99 per 30 g |
13. Core Power 26 g, Strawberry BananaAmazon · $21.50 for 6 | 26 g · 6 g sugar · carrageenan: label too small to read · $4.13 per 30 g |
14. Core Power Elite 42 g, StrawberryAmazon · $34.99 for 6 · reseller | 42 g · 7 g sugar · carrageenan: label too small to read · $4.17 per 30 g |
15. Core Power 26 g, Canadian import, BananaAmazon · $64.99 for 12 · reseller | 26 g · 7 g sugar · carrageenan yes · $6.25 per 30 g |
Source: Amazon label photos Nov 5, 2026; prices Nov 20, 2026*1, 2 · Download CSV · Free to reuse with credit to Fine Print Nutrition
Is Fairlife worth the price?
Not on price alone: 99 of the 156 single-flavor shakes we priced cost less per gram.*1, 2
Among the brands people ask about, Fairlife sits in the middle. Premier Protein is cheaper at $2.51 per 30 g of protein. Orgain is $4.56 and OWYN is $4.62, so both cost more than Fairlife.*1, 2
Part of the price is the milk. Fairlife uses milk that has been filtered to hold more protein. If you care about getting 30 to 42 g of protein from milk without much sugar, the price is fair. If you only want grams of protein for the least money, Premier Protein costs less.*1, 3
The way to pay less for Fairlife is to buy Elite in 12-packs: Core Power Elite 42 g, Chocolate.*1
What is ultra-filtered milk?
Ultra-filtered milk is milk pushed through very fine filters that hold back the large parts, such as protein, and let smaller parts, such as water and some of the milk sugar, pass through.
Fairlife says “Our ultra-filtration process concentrates what makes milk great.” The result is a drink with a lot of protein for its size. The Canadian Core Power label we read names its first ingredient “Ultra-Filtered Partly Skimmed Lactose Free Milk.” The U.S. labels we read start with “Filtered Lowfat Grade A Milk.”*2, 3
The shakes are lactose-free. Fairlife says “we use a lactase enzyme to break down the lactose,” and the Canadian label lists lactase enzyme. Lactose-free does not mean milk-free. All 19 Fairlife and Core Power shakes we read are made with milk, so they are not an option for anyone with a milk allergy.*2, 3
Does Fairlife have carrageenan?
Yes: carrageenan is on 14 of the 19 Fairlife and Core Power labels we read, and on every one where the ingredient list is readable.*2
The other 5 have no ingredient list we could read in the listing photos. That includes the Nutrition Plan shakes. Fairlife says on its own question page, “we use carrageenan as a stabilizer to ensure consistent taste and texture.”*2, 3
Is carrageenan a problem? Federal rules let food makers use it “in the amount necessary for an emulsifier, stabilizer, or thickener in foods.” Europe’s food safety panel looked at it again in 2018. It found no sign of cancer or damage to genes, and it still called its safe daily intake “temporary” until it gets better data.*8, 9
If you would rather skip it, Fairlife is the wrong brand. Premier Protein lists it on 36 of 38 labels, so the choice does not get better there. Orgain and OWYN list it on none of their 35 and 29 labels.*2
Does Fairlife use artificial sweeteners?
Yes: 15 of the 19 Fairlife and Core Power shakes list sucralose, acesulfame potassium or both. 15 list sucralose and 15 list acesulfame potassium.*2
Fairlife says “We use natural and artificial sweeteners in our protein shakes and our chocolate ultra-filtered milk.” Every Core Power ingredient list we read names four sweeteners: monk fruit, stevia, acesulfame potassium and sucralose. The Nutrition Plan bottle front says “with sucralose and acesulfame-potassium.”*2, 3
Has Fairlife been tested for lead?
Not by Consumer Reports: it tested 6 protein shakes for lead in 2025, and none was Fairlife or Core Power.*4, 5
The shakes it did test were OWYN, Quest, Muscle Milk, Optimum Nutrition, Jocko Fuel and Ensure. It wrote that “Dairy-based protein powders and shakes generally had the lowest amounts of lead.” That is a statement about the group. It is not a result for a Fairlife bottle, so we do not call Fairlife clean.*4
For scale, the FDA’s interim level is 8.8 micrograms of lead a day for women who could become pregnant and 2.2 for children. The FDA says no safe level of lead has been found. The one shake Consumer Reports found under its limit, OWYN Pro Elite chocolate, had 0.43 micrograms in a carton, which is 5% of the 8.8 level.*5, 7
Does Core Power have phthalates?
Consumer Reports said the Core Power High Protein Chocolate Milk Shake “had among the highest levels of phthalates of any product it tested.”*6
Phthalates are chemicals used to make plastic soft. Consumer Reports said this in a February 22, 2024 letter urging Fairlife to protect its customers. The letter page gives no amounts, and we found no phthalate test of Core Power Elite, the shake we pick, or of Nutrition Plan.*6
What happened with Fairlife’s lawsuit and animal-welfare video?
Fairlife and the other defendants agreed in 2022 to pay into a $21 million settlement fund in a class action over claims that Fairlife’s ads were false about how its cows were treated. The class notice says “Defendants deny all allegations, and the Court has not decided who is right.”*10
Separately, in June 2019 the Associated Press reported that police were investigating alleged animal abuse at Fair Oaks Farms in Indiana, after the group Animal Recovery Mission released undercover footage.*11
None of this changes what is in the bottle. If how a company treats animals decides what you buy, read the class notice and the news report.*10, 11
Fairlife vs Premier Protein vs Core Power: which is better?
Premier Protein is the better value, and both brands list carrageenan on nearly every label we could read.*1, 2
| Shake | Protein | Calories | Carrageenan on the label | Median per 30 g of protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fairlife Nutrition Plan1 listing | 30 g | 150 | Label too small to read | $3.11 |
| Core Power6 listings | 26 g | 170 | 5 of 6 listings | $4.08 |
| Core Power Elite8 listings | 42 g | 230 | 6 of 8 listings | $3.56 |
| Premier Protein37 listings | 30 g | 160 | 36 of 38 listings | $2.51 |
Choose Premier Protein if price decides it. Choose Core Power Elite if you want the most protein in one bottle: Core Power Elite 42 g, Chocolate. Choose Nutrition Plan if you want the fewest calories and least sugar, and accept that its ingredient list is too small to read. Choose OWYN or Orgain if you want to avoid carrageenan. For the full ranking, see the best protein shake.*2, 12
Questions people ask
- How much protein is in a Fairlife shake?
- A Fairlife Nutrition Plan shake has 30 g of protein and 150 calories, a Core Power shake has 26 g and 170 calories, and a Core Power Elite shake has 42 g and 230 calories. These are the numbers on the label panels we read. Sugar runs from 2 g in Nutrition Plan to 5 or 6 g in Core Power and 7 or 8 g in Elite, with no added sugar.*2
- Are Fairlife protein shakes lactose-free?
- Fairlife says it uses a lactase enzyme to break down the lactose, and the Canadian Core Power label lists lactase enzyme. All 19 Fairlife and Core Power shakes we read are made with milk, so they are not safe for a milk allergy.*2, 3
- Is Core Power the same as Fairlife?
- Core Power is a Fairlife product line, and many Amazon titles read "Fairlife Core Power." Fairlife Nutrition Plan is a different line with less sugar and fewer calories. We read 6 Core Power 26 g and 8 Core Power Elite 42 g single-flavor listings.*2
Review log
- : Prices re-read. The smaller-bottle option is now Core Power 26 g Chocolate, the lower price per bottle today
- : Published
Notes and sources
- Fine Print Ledger: 213 Amazon US listings found for protein shakes on Nov 5, 2026 through Amazon’s own search service. 30 are Fairlife or Core Power; 28 are shakes and 2 are milk jugs, which we left out. 189 ready-to-drink shakes had a label we could read with high or medium confidence, 19 of them Fairlife or Core Power, and 15 of those are single-flavor listings with a price.*1, 2
- Medians use high and medium confidence, single-flavor listings with a price: 15 Fairlife and Core Power and 156 in all. Several listings are from resellers; the table says so.*1, 2
- Carrageenan counts when the label lists it as an ingredient. Sweeteners are the ones named on the ingredient list, or on the front of the bottle where the list was too small to read.*2
- We’d change our pick after a cheaper listing with a readable label, a lost listing, or a lead result for Fairlife. Next check: February 2027. More: best protein shake, best protein bar and how we check.
- Amazon US search results for ready-to-drink protein shakes (Amazon Creators API, Nov 5, 2026): titles, brands, prices and photos for 213 listings, 30 of them Fairlife or Core Power. Prices change often.
- Nutrition Facts panels and ingredient lists in the Amazon listing photos, read by hand, Nov 2026. 189 shakes had a panel we could read, 19 of them Fairlife or Core Power.
- fairlife, "Frequently Asked Questions" (fairlife.com), read Nov 5, 2026. What Fairlife says about its own process, carrageenan, sweeteners and milk.
- Consumer Reports, "Protein Powders and Shakes Contain High Levels of Lead," Oct 14, 2025 (updated Jan 8, 2026) Its lead limit is 0.5 micrograms a day. It says "Dairy-based protein powders and shakes generally had the lowest amounts of lead." Fairlife and Core Power are not on its list.
- Consumer Reports, protein powders and shakes: methodology and test results (PDF), 2025. Micrograms per serving and the flavor tested, for each shake.
- Consumer Reports advocacy, letter to fairlife on plastic chemicals in Core Power High Protein Chocolate Milk Shake, Feb 22, 2024. The page gives no numbers.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration, "Lead in Food and Foodwares" (interim reference levels: 2.2 micrograms a day for children, 8.8 for females of childbearing age), content current as of Jan 6, 2025
- Code of Federal Regulations, 21 CFR 172.620, Carrageenan (2024 edition, GovInfo): may be used "in the amount necessary for an emulsifier, stabilizer, or thickener in foods"
- EFSA Panel on Food Additives and Nutrient Sources added to Food, "Re-evaluation of carrageenan (E 407) and processed Eucheuma seaweed (E 407a) as food additives," EFSA Journal, April 2018 (PubMed 32625873) The panel called its daily intake limit "temporary" until more data came in.
- Class action notice, "If you or your business purchased fairlife or Fair Oaks Farms milk products, you may be entitled to a cash award from a class action settlement," PR Newswire, 2022 (U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, Case 1:19-cv-03924) It says "Defendants deny all allegations, and the Court has not decided who is right."
- Associated Press, "Police investigate alleged animal abuse at popular farm," June 5, 2019 (WTTW)
- Fine Print Nutrition, "What is the best protein shake?"