Omni or Create creatine gummies: which should I buy?

Between the two, Create wins on dose, price and proof. Three Create gummies give 4.5 g of creatine for $1.41 per 5 g; three Omni gummies give 3 g, and 5 g costs $2.45 to $2.78. Create is NSF Certified for Sport. Omni is not on NSF's list.*1–3

Our pick over both is Effective Nutra. Outside labs found 72%, 85% and 102% of the label in Create, so its results are mixed. Effective Nutra tested at 126% of its label, and costs $1.30 per 5 g. See our pick.*4

Our pick over both

Effective Nutra Creatine Gummies, 90 count

Effective Nutra Creatine Gummies

Effective Nutra Creatine Gummies
ProofNo NSF listing; one lab test, 126% of label (NOW Foods, Feb 2024)*5
Creatine5 g in 5 gummies
Cost$1.30 per 5 g (about $39.02 a month)*6
Check price on Amazon

Why a third gummy. Neither Omni nor Create clears our bar. Omni has no outside test, and Create missed its label in two of its three outside tests. Effective Nutra did not miss in its test, so it is the gummy we would buy; see every gummy we checked.*4

If you want Create. Buy a flavor NSF lists by name, such as Watermelon (listing 1622205). It is the better of these two gummies: more creatine per gummy, a lower cost per dose, and an NSF listing. See Create Watermelon on Amazon.*2

Create gives 50% more creatine per gummy

Both sell 90 gummies for 30 days. Create puts 4.5 g of creatine in a day's 3 gummies; Omni puts 3 g, so a 5 g dose of Omni takes 5 gummies and uses up the bag in 18 days. Omni has less sugar per dose. We checked 9 Amazon listings, NSF's register and every public creatine gummy test.*1, 7

Create and Omni creatine gummies side by side
CreateOmni
Creatine per gummy1.5 g1 g
Gummies for 5 g3.35
Cost per 5 g$1.41 (variety pack $2.15)$2.45 to $2.72 (third-party sellers); $2.78 from Omni
Sugar per 5 g of creatine5.6 to 6.7 g (flavors we could read)5.0 g
NSF Certified for SportYes, per flavorNo listing found
Outside lab tests3: 72%, 85% and 102% of labelNone found
Lawsuits over the dose2 class actions filed, no rulingNone found

Source: Amazon labels and prices read Nov 3, 2026; NSF registers; lab tests 2024 to 2025*1–4 · Download CSV · Free to reuse with credit to Fine Print Nutrition

A dose of Omni costs more than a dose of Create

Per 5 g of creatine, Create costs $1.41. Omni costs $2.45 to $2.72 from third-party sellers and $2.78 from Omni itself, because each gummy holds less.*1

Cost per 5 g of creatine, from each label and Amazon prices read Nov 3, 2026 (Effective Nutra: Nov 20, 2026). Black = our pick.

Our pick: Effective Nutra$1.30Create (6 flavors)$1.41Omni Peach, other seller$2.45Omni Watermelon, other seller$2.72Omni, from Omni$2.78

Source: Amazon prices read Nov 3, 2026*1, 6 · Download CSV · Free to reuse with credit to Fine Print Nutrition

Create passed 1 of 3 outside lab tests

SuppCo found 102% of the label. NOW Foods found 85% and James Smith 72%. Create's own paid tests in March 2024 found 94% to 102%; we show them but don't count them. Two lawsuits say their labs found less than the label. We found no ruling in either.*4, 10, 11

Every published test of Create creatine gummies
Who testedCreatine found vs labelWhen
NOW FoodsLab of a rival brand (NOW sells creatine)85%Feb 2024*5
SuppCoSupplement-rating app, outside lab102%Jun 2025*8
James Smith (YouTube)YouTube creator, paid for it himself72%Jul 2025*9
Connolly lawsuitPlaintiff's lab, Orange flavor; a claim, not a finding89%Apr 2026*10
Macartney lawsuitPlaintiff's lab, July 2025 sample; a claim, not a finding80%Dec 2025*11

Source: lab tests 2024 to 2025; court complaints 2025 to 2026*4 · Download CSV · Free to reuse with credit to Fine Print Nutrition

How to check any creatine gummy before you buy

  1. Find grams per gummy on the panel. Divide the creatine line by the gummies per serving. Under 1.5 g means a 5 g dose takes 4 or more gummies.
  2. Look up your flavor on NSF's site. NSF lists gummies flavor by flavor. Search the brand at nsfsport.com.
  3. Count the cost per 5 g, not per bag. Two bags at the same price can hold very different amounts of creatine.

Questions people ask

Is Omni creatine underdosed?
Not against its own label: Omni says 3 gummies give 3 g. But most studies use 3 to 5 g a day, so for 5 g you need 5 Omni gummies. We found no lab test of Omni. See how much to take.
Is Create creatine legit?
It is NSF Certified for Sport by flavor. Its outside lab test results range from 72% to 102% of the label, and two lawsuits over its dose have been filed. We found no ruling in either.
Which has less sugar, Omni or Create?
Omni. Per 5 g of creatine, Omni has 5 g of sugar and Create 5.6 to 6.7 g.
Is there a cheaper gummy with proof?
Yes. Effective Nutra passes our rule and costs less per dose than either. See alternatives to Create and creatine gummies for women.

Review log

  • : Gummy pick now follows today's Amazon prices
  • : Force Factor pick set to the Watermelon 150-count listing (NSF 1779383)
  • : Published

Notes and sources

  • Listings read Nov 3, 2026: Create Watermelon, Blue Raspberry, Sour Peach, Sour Cherry, Sour Apple, Orange and the Variety Pack; Omni Peach and Watermelon. Sugar for Create Sour Apple, Orange and the Variety Pack was not on a panel we could read.
  • Omni's lowest Amazon prices are from resellers, not the brand, so the lot and the price can change. Omni says its gummies are "lab-verified" but names no lab and posts no result.
  • Lab results use the rule from our gummies page: met = at least 90% of the label in every independent test. NOW Foods sells creatine; we count its tests and say so. Lawsuit numbers are claims in complaints, not findings by a court.
  • Photo is an illustration. The data file is free to reuse with credit to Fine Print Nutrition.
  1. Amazon.com listings for Create (6 flavors) and Omni (2 flavors), price, seller and Supplement Facts panel read Nov 3, 2026 Each listing and panel source is in the data file. Omni's lowest prices are from resellers; Omni's own offer was $49.99.
  2. NSF Certified for Sport listings for Create creatine gummies (per flavor), read Nov 3, 2026
  3. NSF Certified for Sport search for "omni", read Nov 3, 2026 (no Omni creatine listed)
  4. Fine Print Nutrition, "Do creatine gummies actually have creatine?" (29 lab results for 25 brands; data.csv) Met the label = at least 90% in every independent test.
  5. NOW Foods, creatine gummy test results, February 2024 NOW sells creatine; we count its tests but mark the source.
  6. Amazon.com price for Effective Nutra gummies, read through the Amazon Product Advertising API, Nov 20, 2026 Prices change often.
  7. Omni, creatine gummy product page ("Three gummies = 3g of pure, lab-verified creatine monohydrate"), read Nov 3, 2026 The page names no lab and posts no test result.
  8. SuppCo, "SuppCo Tested: Creatine" report, June 12, 2025 (PDF) SuppCo runs a supplement app. Its report says an independent, ISO 17025-certified lab ran the tests.
  9. NutraIngredients, "Are creatine gummies a viable delivery format?", July 8, 2025 (James Smith's Eurofins test of 9 gummy brands) Smith is a YouTube creator; he bought his samples outside the US.
  10. Connolly v. Create Wellness, Inc., S.D.N.Y. No. 7:26-cv-03324, complaint filed April 22, 2026 A claim in a complaint, not a court finding.
  11. Macartney v. Create Wellness, Inc., N.D. Cal. No. 5:25-cv-10713, complaint filed December 16, 2025 (copy hosted by Truth in Advertising) A claim in a complaint, not a court finding. It cites a July 2025 result of 3.62 g per 4.5 g serving and a July 2024 sample with almost none.